Uncategorized
FA must let common sense prevail as Liverpool charge would be mad after PGMOL admission on VAR
FA must let common sense prevail as Liverpool charge would be mad after PGMOL admission on VAR
At least one Liverpool player is technically open to an FA charge after venting his frustrations following a VAR shambles. Common sense simply has to prevail.
SHARE
ByJames MartinLiverpool Writer
Bookmark
There is an urgent need for the FA to exercise common sense as one or more Liverpool players face possible charges. (Image: Photo by Charlotte Wilson/Offside/Offside via Getty Images)
The fallout from the VAR error in Liverpool vs Spurs has been in line with the magnitude of the mistake. Surely the worst blunder in the Premier League since the technology was introduced, it has remained a talking point more than 48 hours after the match ended.
Far more galling than a bad subjective call, this is an error that has been specifically borne of the technology. Of course, Liverpool would not have been awarded the goal without VAR either, with the on-field assistant wrongly calling offside, but a failure to intervene on the basis of an erroneous ‘check complete’ call when the opposite was intended is far harder to stomach than a rogue flag.
Never before have all of the officials been near-instantly aware that a grave game-altering error has been made, yet felt powerless to alter it. Presumably, nobody was prepared to make the call that the circumstances warranted overriding VAR protocol — and with Spurs scoring soon afterwards, the situation rapidly became utterly irrevocable.
READ MORE: Transfer ‘watched’ by Liverpool might explain Jürgen Klopp future plan amid Joe Gomez question
READ MORE: Liverpool $63m transfer duo are about to show why Jürgen Klopp signed them as major chance looms
Common sense certainly did not prevail. But there is a chance for the FA, at least, to use some of it as it assesses the fallout from the incident.
Naturally, Liverpool players and staff were aghast at the outcome. To his eternal credit, Jürgen Klopp was remarkably restrained in his post-match interview given the circumstances, but some of his players let their emotions get the better of them a little more.
In particular, Alexis Mac Allister has undoubtedly opened himself up to the technical possibility of an FA charge, as the Metro reports. In a heated and since-deleted exchange with international teammate Cristian Romero on Instagram, the Liverpool midfielder said the Spurs victory was ‘normal when you have 12 players’.
By the letter of the law, the FA probably feels bound to find that this is questioning the integrity of a match official. That warrants a charge. But in the circumstances, to enforce that would be utterly ridiculous.
Sign up for our EXCLUSIVE Liverpool.com newsletter!
If you enjoyed this piece, you’ll love our Liverpool.com newsletter — every weekday, we send exclusive, bonus content only to people signed up for our mailing list!
Our newsletter subscribers get a rundown Monday to Friday from one of the best Liverpool FC writers — straight to your inbox, and completely for free.
Wherever you are in the world — in the US, the UK or further afield — you don’t want to miss out.
Sign up to the Liverpool.com newsletter here — it only takes a few seconds!
The integrity of the match officiating is already a lost cause. A perfectly valid goal was chalked off because of an administrative error: the PGMOL has admitted that the VAR process failed miserably. While the referees were not on Tottenham’s side, as Mac Allister implied, they categorically handed Spurs the victory by way of their decision-making.
Players are already expected to be like robots in the sheer amount of football they are made to play. Now, they are being asked never to show any emotion either. Frankly, even Mac Allister’s outburst is relatively restrained in the context of the scale of the injustice perpetuated against Liverpool.
It’s too late to salvage much from this incident, which has left the reputation of VAR and the PGMOL in tatters. But the FA, at least, can use a little bit of common sense, ensuring that the situation does not contrive to get even worse.
Follow Liverpool.com
Comment
MORE ON
Liverpool FCFAAlexis Mac Allister
LIVERPOOL FC NEWS
ALL
TOP STORIES
FA must let common sense prevail as Liverpool charge would be mad after PGMOL admission on VAR
LIVERPOOL FC
Transfer ‘watched’ by Liverpool might explain Jürgen Klopp future plan amid Joe Gomez question
LIVERPOOL FC
Liverpool $63m transfer duo are about to show why Jürgen Klopp signed them as major chance looms
LIVERPOOL FC
Liverpool should seek wonderkid with Real Madrid and Barcelona DNA as Mohamed Salah transfer heir
LIVERPOOL FC
Europa League opponents take pop at Liverpool as Erik ten Hag lends support to referees
MEDIA DIGEST
Liverpool squad has its say on VAR saga as Barcelona ‘ready to sell’ star amid transfer link
FOOTBALL BLOG
Dominik Szoboszlai is Liverpool’s ‘extra man’ who almost helped Jürgen Klopp do the impossible
DOMINIK SZOBOSZLAI
Jürgen Klopp needs new Mohamed Salah and Darwin Núñez ‘counterweight’ if Liverpool appeal fails
LIVERPOOL FC
Liverpool transfer news as ace tipped to be ‘high up’ Mohamed Salah list and Spurs may land blow
LIVERPOOL FC
Liverpool can handle new Premier League rules better than anyone and Ange Postecoglou knows why
LIVERPOOL FC
Gary Lineker disagrees with Micah Richards amid call to ‘scrap VAR’ after Liverpool controversy
LIVERPOOL FC
Everything Liverpool squad said about VAR error as Alexis Mac Allister may face punishment
LIVERPOOL FC
LIVERPOOL FC NEWS
TRANSFER NEWS
SCHEDULE
FEATURES
PREMIER LEAGUE
FOLLOW US
About Us
Contact Us
RSS Feeds
Newsletter Signup
Syndication & Licensing
T&Cs
Cookie Policy
Competition Rules
How to Complain
Corrections & Clarifications
Privacy Notice
Do not sell or share my data
© 2023 a Reach plc subsidiary
Liverpool’s ultimate aim in bitter VAR row becomes clear as new evidence comes to light
Liverpool are seeking answers from the PGMOL over their disallowed goal in Saturday’s 2-1 defeat to Tottenham, but they do not want a replay contrary to some suggestions
VIDEO LOADING
Jurgen Klopp reviews the Tottenham Hotspur game
NEWS
POLITICS
FOOTBALL
CELEBS
TV
CHOICE
ByMark JonesSports Features Editor
21:22, 2 Oct 2023UPDATED23:51, 2 OCT 2023
|
52
|
BOOKMARK
Liverpool are committed to wanting a thorough investigation into Saturday’s remarkable Video Assistant Referee error at Tottenham, with the singling out of individuals not deemed to be good enough.
VAR Darren England and Assistant VAR Dan Cook were stood down from their duties for matches on Sunday and Monday after effectively disallowing a Luis Diaz goal by deciding to award it.
Somehow both England and Cook had mistakenly believed Diaz had not been flagged offside when he ran through to put the 10-man Reds ahead at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, and so when they quickly told referee Simon Hooper it was “check complete” on the call they were inadvertently backing the assistant referee’s incorrect offside decision, with Diaz clearly onside.
Jamie Carragher explains “big problem” with Curtis Jones’ red card as Liverpool appeal
Sky Sports provide new evidence on Luis Diaz disallowed goal as Jamie Carragher fumes
Sky Sports reported on Monday night that England and Cook did then become aware of their error but, with Tottenham having taken their free-kick to restart the game, they then felt that they were unable to stop the match and award the goal in their capacities as VARs. It is claimed that Hooper, who was working as a fourth official at Fulham against Chelsea on Monday night, was only made aware of the mistake at half-time.
In the past when high profile and controversial errors have been made the officials responsible have been stood down for the next game or games, but Liverpool believe that simply will not cut it this time given the unprecedented nature of the error.
Luis Diaz had his goal at Tottenham disallowed
Luis Diaz had his goal at Tottenham disallowed ( Image: Getty Images)
While not wanting to scapegoat England and Cook, the Reds are demanding transparency and a comprehensive review into one of the strangest decisions ever seen in the Premier League.
In a strongly-worded statement on Sunday evening the club said they would explore options available to them, citing a “clear need for escalation and resolution” to the problem. This does not mean that they will demand to replay the game despite suggestions to the contrary. It is purely confirmation that they do not accept the PGMOL’s explanation of “significant human error” to be adequate.
Saturday’s referee Simon Hooper was fourth official at Fulham vs Chelsea on Monday ( Image: PA)
A current official has dismissed the idea that England and Cook were not allowed to intervene and correct their error, telling Sky Sports: “This is not about a subjective call, it is a goal – checked and confirmed – that wasn’t given through, I would say, not one but a series of failings. It could have and should have been immediately corrected regardless of normal protocol given how many people are in the control room or are listening in. This was not a normal situation.
“I have to say there’s a question management should answer too, it cannot just be on one person.”
The fact that England, Cook and fourth official Michael Oliver were all working in the UAE 48 hours before the Tottenham match is also thought to be something Liverpool are seeking answers on.
Again speaking to Sky Sports, former Reds defender Jamie Carragher said on Monday night: “There has been criticism of the officials going abroad midweek. I don’t have a problem with that because a lot of our officials referee in the Champions League and Europa League and come back.
This article contains affiliate links, we will receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more
Watch the Premier League, Champions League and more
Watch the Premier League, Champions League, Europa League and much more
TNT Sports gives you access to games across the Premier League, Champions League, Europa League, Serie A and many more. You can also watch the biggest clashes in boxing, UFC, WWE and the get exclusive action from MLB all for one payment every month. You can watch TNT Sports through BT, EE, Sky, and Virgin Media.
£29.99 a month and get access to discovery+ Premium at no extra costTNT SPORTS
Get it here
“What I would say is if officials are going to another country because they are better than the officials there, why can’t that work the other way? We are talking about how this season has not been good enough, Howard Webb knows that and the officials know that.
“If our officials are going abroad, why can’t we, the Premier League, the best league in the world with the most eyes on it, why can’t we have the best referees and best VAR officials coming to our country?”
Join our new WhatsApp community! Click this link to receive your daily dose of Mirror Football content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don’t like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you’re curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
READ MORE
Top Liverpool stories
Liverpool issue explosive VAR statement
Reds face FA fine
Neville hits back at Liverpool statement
Premier League take action
READ NEXT:
Sky Sports provide new evidence on Luis Diaz disallowed goal as Jamie Carragher fumes
Mikel Arteta backs Liverpool in heated VAR row and wants Reds to “get what they deserve”
Jamie Carragher explains “big problem” with Curtis Jones’ red card as Liverpool appeal
Howard Webb to agree to Liverpool audio request as PGMOL set for major VAR overhaul
Liverpool’s stinging VAR statement could force two major changes to how system operates
FollowMirror
Comments
52
MORE ON
LIVERPOOL FC
TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR FC
VIDEO ASSISTANT REFEREE
What do Liverpool need to clinch the title? Keep up with all the Reds news with our FREE daily newsletter
Enter your email…
Sign up
HomeSportFootballLiverpool FC
TOP STORIES
‘HE TOLD ME HE LOVED ME…’ I’m A Celebrity and X Factor star Jake Quickenden reveals his heartbreaking final words to his little brother before tragic death
JAKE QUICKENDEN
REVEALED: What caused massive fireball lighting up night sky for miles with loud bang causing panic
ACCIDENTS
Pathetic excuse given by football yob who has lost his job after mocking Bradley Lowery
BRADLEY LOWERY
Gemma Atkinson flooded with messages from concerned fans over photo of sleeping son
GEMMA ATKINSON
Man City hero Francis Lee was an England star, toilet roll millionaire and so much more
FA CUP
REPAIR TO THE THRONE: King Charles allows Andrew to remain at his Royal Lodge home after thrashing out a deal with disgraced prince – FULL DETAILS
PRINCE ANDREW, DUKE OF YORK
Abducted girl found ‘in good health’ and suspect in custody after park kidnapping
MISSING PERSONS
BBC Panorama claims Abercrombie & Fitch fashion boss recruited for ‘sex events’
PANORAMA
Shirley Ballas sent terrifying coffin drawings as death threats spark safety fears
SHIRLEY BALLAS
Highly-mutated Covid Pirola strain now ‘in most UK regions’ – full list of symptoms
CORONAVIRUS
‘The dangers women and girls face tend not to be fully appreciated until it is too late’
WOMEN
UK set to be hotter than Barcelona, Venice and Istanbul as Indian Summer arrives in days
WEATHER
6
POPULAR TOPICS
News
Weird News
Travel
Tech
Politics
Showbiz
Life & Style
Mums
Football
Family
Money
Film
TV
Sport
Fashion
TeamDogs
Motoring
SUBSCRIBE
Keep up to date with all the latest news
Enter your email…Sign up
We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you’ve consented to and improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. More Info.
Newsletter preference centre
Subscribe to Daily Mirror and Sunday Mirror newspapers
Subscribe to tablet edition
OUR PARTNERS
Sports Betting & Casino
Beauty Box Subscription
Mirror Bingo
Crosswords, Puzzles & Games
Memory Lane
Betting
Freebets
Partner Stories
SUPPORT
How to Complain
Notifications and alerts help
Corrections and Clarifications
COMPANY
About Us
Work for us
Contact Us
Irish Mirror
Syndication & Licensing
Sell your story
RESOURCES
Marketplace
Find a local business
F♥ind a job
Shop
Discount codes
InYourArea
©2023 a Reach plc subsidiary
Do not sell or share my dataPrivacy NoticeCookie NoticeTerms and ConditionsCommunity Standards
-
Manchester City9 months ago
Congratulations Phil Foden side chick just gave birth to a baby boy,open to hear Phil Foden speech from conference
-
Manchester City8 months ago
Good New: Erling Haaland UK side chick just delivered a baby boy today, Haaland named the child after Pep Guardiola 🙄
-
Manchester City8 months ago
Report: Manchester City attacking midfielder De Bruyne ‘desperate’ to join English football giants
-
Manchester City9 months ago
Congratulations: Erling Haaland become a father as side chick delivered baby boy earlier today by BBC..
-
Manchester City7 months ago
Footage of Ederson’s Angry Reaction to Pep Guardiola made Phil Foden to send him a warning massage,Pep was shocked when he saw what Phil wrote.
-
Manchester City6 months ago
“Everyone at Man City wants me out, even the fans want me out
-
Uncategorized6 months ago
Sky Sport Confirmed Tottenham has signed Manchester City best player€66m rated,Ange Postecoglou smile
-
Manchester City8 months ago
Congratulations to Phil Foden as he bought a new private jet.